Learn how to make vanilla extract at home with this very simple and cost effective tutorial, requiring only two ingredients and a little time. Store-bought high-quality vanilla extract is expensive, but it’s a pantry staple due to its rich, warm flavor. Imitation vanilla is just that – synthetic. This recipe is a much better option and just as delicious.
This post contains affiliate links for your convenience. See my full disclosure here.
I love to make homemade vanilla extract. It is very simple, works beautifully in so many of my recipes (like sourdough discard cinnamon bread), and tastes so much better than the cheap stuff found in the grocery stores.
Real vanilla can be expensive, but it is worth the additional cost.
However, when you make it at home, the taste is even more pure and delicious. You get every part of the vanilla bean, including the fragrant seeds inside the pods.
The basic science goes like this: When an herb with desirable properties is placed in a preserving liquid, like glycerin, vinegar, or alcohol, the beneficial components/taste/properties are infused into the liquid.
Alcohol is a potent solvent and yields a more concentrated tincture.
Putting together a batch of homemade vanilla extract is as simple as placing vanilla beans in your preferred alcohol choice and letting time do the work.
Why You Will Love Homemade Vanilla Extract
Best flavor: Homemade extract has such a delightful vanilla flavor, much better than what you would find at the store, and far better than imitation vanilla. It’s warm, rich, and versatile.
Makes a great gift: Alongside a pretty tea towel and beeswax candle, homemade vanilla makes a super simple, thoughtful, handmade Christmas gift for the holiday season.
If you aren’t able to start the vanilla four months before, just put a little note on the jar that says “Ready to enjoy in February”.
Cheaper: Making vanilla yourself is much more cost-efficient than buying it from the store.
Ingredients
Vanilla: I have made this recipe from many different types of beans, including both Tahitian vanilla beans and Madagascar beans. Usually, I just purchase them from Amazon.
After doing a little research, including this article on Pastry Chef Online, the best bean for culinary purposes is pure Madagascar vanilla beans.
Vodka: Homemade vanilla extract made in vodka tastes most like the good, old-fashioned, pure vanilla you’re used to. Rum or bourbon will add a rich flavor, but I typically use vodka because it works great and is less expensive.
Tools
How To Make Vanilla Extract
Step 1: Cut whole vanilla beans down the center longways.
Step 2: Place the vanilla beans in your vessel of choice. Depending on the size of your jar, you may or may not need to cut the beans in half to fit.
For this application, I am using the same wares I use for everything else: the humble Mason jar. I have them in every size.
Step 3: Cover the vanilla beans with alcohol.
Step 4: Allow the vanilla to infuse into the alcohol. Shake occasionally. You will know it’s ready when the extract no longer smells like alcohol. This usually takes about four months.
Storage
Store in a cool, dark place out of direct sunlight. This recipe has a very long shelf life and will stay good for over a year.
How To Use Homemade Vanilla Extract
- Use it as you would normally use store-bought vanilla extract in baking.
- Sprinkle it in homemade yogurt or vanilla ice cream.
- Use it in grain-free granola.
- Add it to your morning coffee.
- Add some to a homemade smoothie.
- One last strange tip: Supposedly, pure vanilla extract rubbed on the skin makes a great bug-repellant.
Tips
- Make sure to store it at room temperature out of direct sunlight.
- You can reuse vanilla beans to make another batch of extract a few times. So don’t just toss them as soon as you are done.
- After you are done making vanilla extract, use those pods to make vanilla sugar! Give the pods time to dry completely, then place them into a glass jar of sugar and top with a lid. Give the sugar about two weeks to “steep” for best results.
- Store in a cool, dark place. Homemade extracts will last a very long time due to the nature of the ingredients.
Recipe FAQs
Vanilla extract is typically made from vodka, but rum, bourbon or even brandy will work. Each will provide a different flavor. Luckily, whichever base you choose, it doesn’t need to be expensive. Pick an inexpensive alcohol since the vanilla is the star of the show.
Vanilla extract is an infusion of vanilla bean pods in an alcohol that is given time for the flavor to develop.
The ratio is 8-12 vanilla beans per 16 ounces of alcohol. So if you want to make 8 ounces of extract, use 4-6 beans.
You can reuse vanilla beans 2-4 times to make a new batch of extract. The more times you use them, the weaker the extract will be. Some find that they prefer the flavor the first time around, but others prefer the vanilla flavor when using the beans the second or third time.
Find more delicious recipes from the farmhouse:
- Sourdough Beignets
- Sourdough Brioche Cinnamon Rolls
- Homemade Brioche Donuts with Vanilla Custard Filling
- Raw Milk Ice Cream
If you try this recipe and love it, I would love it if you could come back and give it 5 stars! Tag me on Instagram @farmhouseonboone.
Vanilla Extract
Ingredients
- 12 vanilla beans
- 16 oz vodka, rum, bourbon, or brandy
Instructions
- Cut whole vanilla beans down the center longways.
- Place the vanilla beans in your vessel of choice. Depending on the size of your jar, you may or may not need to cut the beans in half to fit.
- Cover the vanilla beans with alcohol.
- Allow the vanilla to infuse into the alcohol. Shake occasionally. You will know it’s ready when the extract no longer smells like alcohol. This usually takes about four months.
Notes
- Make sure to store it at room temperature out of direct sunlight.
- You can reuse vanilla beans to make another batch of extract a few times. So don’t just toss them as soon as you are done.
- After you are done making vanilla extract, use those pods to make vanilla sugar! Give the pods time to dry completely, then place them into a glass jar of sugar and top with a lid. Give the sugar about two weeks to “steep” for best results.
- Store in a cool, dark place. Homemade extracts will last a very long time due to the nature of the ingredients.
Nutrition
Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.
Where do you buy good quality vanilla beans in bulk?
There’s a group on facebook called Indri’s Vanilla Beans. I like to purchase mine there.
Adds a delicious, warm flavor to so many recipes. My family likes the flecks of the seeds and the taste it adds to pound cake.
How many vanilla beans do you put in each jar?
12!
I have been making vanilla extract for years and once you do, you will never, ever buy vanilla again. We love the flavor. I give it to my Daughter and Daughter’s-in-love and now my married grands! They love getting a big bottle for Christmas in their stockings. 🙂
Do you remove the vanilla beans after 4 months or just leave them in the bottle?
It’s all preference! Some keep their vanilla beans in the jar for up to a year. You can also reuse the beans by putting more alcohol in a jar with the beans. They won’t be as strong though. You can also use them to make vanilla paste! So many options.
What happens if the vodka is only 40%.
You really want the highest proof to best extract the vanilla.
How do store extra vanilla beans until needed?
You can store them in sugar. Make sure they are completely covered in the sugar and that will help keep them for longer.
I am sooo excited to use my homemade Vanilla. I just screwed the tops onto 3 jars. I am giving 1 jar to each of my daughters for Mother’s Day. I am attaching a label saying “Ready to use in September 2024”.
Your plastic mason jar link product is unavailable. Just so you are aware.
Thank you for letting me know.
Can’t wait to try this recipe! Do you have exact measurements for the vanilla vodka ratio, or is it not that specific? Thanks!!
The FDA requires 2.64 ounces (by weight) to 750mL 70-100 proof alcohol. An easier formula is 1 ounces of beans (by weight) to 8 ounces alcohol (by volume).
How is 75g beans to 750ml vodka not the easier option? Metric is always easier. This formula is rly easy as it’s 75:750!